Direction, and company
I rode south to north, which is the less common way to do it. That decides more than it sounds like it should.
Most people ride the Americas north to south. Starting in Buenos Aires and finishing on the Arctic Ocean puts you head-on into everyone else.
The result is that you meet a great many overlanders and you tend to meet each of them exactly once. You pass in a border queue or a hostel car park, swap what you know about the road behind you for what they know about the road ahead, and then ride off in opposite directions. The information is excellent. The company is brief.
It is worth knowing before you choose a direction. If you want to fall in with people and ride together for weeks, go the way everyone else is going. If you want a constant supply of fresh, current road information from people who were there yesterday, go the other way.
In Colombia I fell in with a group of five Brazilians heading north, and rode with them through Central America.
Being five rather than one helped at checkpoints and through the stretches you would rather not linger in. Whether it genuinely made a difference I cannot prove. It certainly felt like it did.
Where it definitely made a difference was the paperwork. Central American border crossings are Monty Python levels of bureaucratic, and they became a great deal more bearable in the company of four other people who were equally annoyed by them. The same is true of the two weeks in San Pedro Sula waiting for customs to release the bikes. Alone that is a grind. Together it is at least a shared one.
Riding against the traffic means a constant supply of warnings, and they follow a pattern. In Argentina I was warned about Peru. In Chile I was warned about Bolivia. In Ecuador I was warned about Colombia.
You learn to ask the right questions of the right people, and you learn that mostly it will be fine. There are places you should not go and there is a real possibility of theft or worse, but almost none of that comes from the country immediately north of wherever you happen to be standing.
The bikes that went around Nicaragua by container were theirs and mine together, which is why there is a Brazilian-plated GS in the photographs on the shipping page.